Every app on Earth is now open source... whether it likes it or not

Software Fireship · 5m 56s · Watch on YouTube · 17 sources

Decision Card

Effort: Afternoon project: run npx rea-agents setup against your coding agent, install Ghidra (free), and point it at one small binary you own to see what pseudocode and token usage you get. Budget 2–4 hours plus the agent tokens. One user reports 80K–230K tokens to inspect an ordinary Mac app.

Honest take: The video says these tools have made “every app” open source, and then shows the opposite. The flagship clone, FilmCraft, lags and has poor transitions. Thomas himself puts the suite at about 50% parity. REA’s own disclaimer says its output “may be incomplete or incorrect” and that it does not “automatically clone a program.” Several details are also wrong: REA’s README does not mention JVM bytecode or OCI layers, and DaVinci Resolve is proprietary, not open source.

Concrete next steps:

  • Read the REA README and DISCLAIMER at https://github.com/morluto/rea before installing. Install only from the official repo or the rea-agents npm package, because a fake copy has been reported to spread a Windows trojan (~20 min).
  • Look through the open issues on https://github.com/storytold/photocraft (CMYK, ICC profiles, PSD compositing, memory use) to judge whether the ArtCraft apps could handle real work yet (~30 min).
  • Repeat the video’s workflow on one feature of a binary you are licensed to analyse: REA plus Ghidra produces pseudocode, then a coding agent re-implements it. Compare the result with an agent working only from screenshots, as MindStudio did (half a day).
  • Skip if you only want a free Premiere replacement today. DaVinci Resolve’s free edition is mature, and the Rust clones are early alpha.

TL;DR

Fireship covers ArtCraft, Brandon Thomas’s Claude-built Rust clones of seven Adobe Creative Cloud apps, and REA (“Reverse Engineer Anything”), a viral MCP server that connects coding agents to decompilers like Ghidra. The video argues that decompiling any binary and handing the pseudocode to an AI makes all software effectively open source, but its own test shows the results are still rough.

Key Points

  • Brandon Thomas got fed up with Adobe’s cancellation fees and used Claude to build seven Rust replacements for Creative Cloud apps (Photoshop, Illustrator, Premiere and others), released free and open source as ArtCraft. 00:02
  • The ArtCraft apps run on Linux, which Adobe has never officially supported. 00:25
  • REA is presented as able to decompile stripped ELF/PE/Mach-O binaries, JVM bytecode, .NET assemblies, firmware and container layers, which leads to the claim that “virtually every app” is now open source. 00:35
  • In hands-on use, FilmCraft (the Premiere clone) copies the Premiere UI almost exactly but has audio-meter lag, general slowness, and poor transitions. 01:43
  • The host’s alternative is to reverse-engineer only the Premiere features you actually use and build a slimmer “Premiere Light”. 02:35
  • The workflow: run REA through Node/npx, configure its Ghidra integration (which “deserves the most credit”), then ask the agent to inspect a locally installed app. 03:22
  • REA returns C-like pseudocode, assembly, strings, symbols and references, which you then give to a coding agent to re-implement in Rust. 03:49
  • REA’s networking features can also analyse a SaaS product’s API calls and UI changes so you can build a clone of the backend. The Supabase→“Studbase” example and its benchmark are a joke. 04:25
  • Sponsor segment: Apify’s MCP server exposes a handful of core tools that find and run “actors” to keep token use down. 04:58

Notable Quotes

  • “virtually every app in the world is now open-source, whether it wants to be or not.” 00:59
  • “configure REA’s Ghidra integration, which is actually the tool that deserves the most credit here” 03:26
  • “orders of magnitude and faster according to this benchmark I just made up. Trust me, bro.” 04:49

Verified Claims

  • Claim: Brandon Thomas used Claude to build seven free, open-source Rust apps replacing Adobe Creative Cloud tools, called ArtCraft. 00:02
    • Sources: PetaPixel, TweakTown
    • Verdict: Confirmed. Coverage lists PhotoCraft, VectorCraft, FilmCraft, LightCraft, EffectCraft, DesignCraft and PrintCraft, reportedly built with Claude Opus 5.5.
  • Claim: The apps run on Linux. 00:25
  • Claim: Thomas “reverse-engineered Adobe’s 30-plus-year code base” and made the suite obsolete. 00:21
    • Sources: Akita on Rails analysis, PhotoCraft repo
    • Verdict: Disputed. Thomas himself estimates about 50% parity. PhotoCraft is labelled “early alpha” and has 800+ open issues (colour management, PSD compositing, memory). Critics describe it as a UI facsimile, not a decompiled port.
  • Claim: Adobe charges cancellation fees on its subscriptions. 00:15
    • Sources: TechSpot on FTC/DOJ lawsuit, InformationWeek
    • Verdict: Confirmed. In June 2024 the FTC/DOJ sued over the early termination fee on the “annual paid monthly” plan, which is 50% of the remaining payments.
  • Claim: REA decompiles stripped ELF, PE and Mach-O binaries, JVM bytecode, .NET assemblies, firmware and OCI container layers. 00:42
    • Sources: REA GitHub README
    • Verdict: Disputed (overstated). The README lists ELF, PE, thin Mach-O, .NET and firmware, but does not mention JVM bytecode or OCI images. Native analysis depends on external backends (Ghidra/Hopper/IDA).
  • Claim: REA is set up with Node.js/npx and relies on Ghidra for native EXE/DLL analysis. 03:22
    • Sources: REA GitHub README, MindStudio explainer
    • Verdict: Confirmed. Setup is npx rea-agents setup on Node 22+. REA is “a connector, not a new reverse engineering technology,” wrapping Ghidra, Hopper, IDA and others.
  • Claim: REA can analyse network/API interactions of an app. 04:37
    • Sources: REA GitHub README
    • Verdict: Confirmed. It supports HAR/SAZ captures, mitmproxy, TShark, and browser network observation.
  • Claim: DaVinci Resolve has been an open-source alternative for over 20 years. 01:43
    • Sources: Wikipedia: DaVinci Resolve
    • Verdict: Disputed. Resolve is proprietary freeware with a paid Studio edition. It is free to use but not open source.
  • Claim: The host pays Adobe about $69/month for Premiere. 01:34
    • Sources: ThePricer, Photutorial
    • Verdict: Confirmed with caveat. $69.99/month is the Creative Cloud Pro (all apps) price. Premiere Pro alone is $22.99/month on an annual plan.
  • Claim: Supabase is “basically a wrapper on top of AWS.” 04:25
    • Sources: Supabase architecture docs
    • Verdict: Disputed. Supabase is an open-source stack built around Postgres (PostgREST, GoTrue, Realtime and others). Calling it an AWS wrapper is a joke, not a fact.

Tools, Papers & Standards Mentioned

Follow-up Questions

  1. How well does REA plus a coding agent actually re-implement a non-trivial feature (for example a Premiere timeline operation), compared with an agent working from screenshots and docs alone? What does it cost in tokens per feature?
  2. Where is the legal line for this workflow? How do EULA anti-reverse-engineering clauses, DMCA §1201, and EU interoperability exceptions apply to decompiling a commercial app and re-implementing features from the pseudocode?
  3. Will ArtCraft’s AI-written Rust codebase ever handle the “hard parts” of creative tools (colour management, ICC/CMYK, PSD compatibility, GPU pipelines), or does that domain knowledge sit outside anything a binary can reveal?

Sources