The Game Prototype That Had to Be Banned by Its Own Studio
Decision Card
Effort: One evening to read the rules and set up a paper grid or the community Discord bot, then a commitment of 1–3 weeks of daily check-ins from 8–17 players to actually run a game.
Honest take: The whole story rests on a single unfinished playthrough by 17 colleagues, told almost entirely by its designer, so “the game is psychologically dangerous” is confounded with “it was played at work, across reporting lines, in a glass-walled room”. The video also leaves out Muscat’s own GDC diagnosis (no randomness, so every loss is someone’s fault) and that his later anonymous-alias games did not fix the bad feeling.
Concrete next steps:
- Read the Engadget write-up of the GDC talk for the design analysis the video skips (10 min).
- Watch or skim the primary source, Muscat’s GDC 2013 session “The Prototype that was Banned from Halfbrick” (about 1 hour; may need GDC Vault access).
- Try the mechanics with a low-stakes group using the Tank Tactics Discord bot (an evening to set up, then days to weeks of play).
- Skip if you only want the anecdote: the TL;DR and Key Points cover it, and the last third of the video is the presenter’s own Neptune’s Pride and Subterfuge stories plus a Patreon plug.
TL;DR
In 2012 Halfbrick designers Luke Muscat and Joe Gatling ran a paper prototype called Tank Tactics with 17 staff, in which players got one action point a day and could gift points to neighbours, making trust the real resource. Within eight days it had produced mass alliances, backstabs, paid spies, anonymous emails and broken working relationships, so the studio stopped the game and never finished it.
Key Points
- Tank Tactics was designed at Halfbrick (Fruit Ninja, Jetpack Joyride) in 2012 as a game people would obsess over and discuss outside the game itself, inspired by the ubiquity of Words with Friends. 01:11
- The rules are minimal: 17 tanks placed at random on a grid, 3 hit points each, a range stat, and action points spent to shoot, move or upgrade range; last player standing wins. 02:25
- Players receive exactly one action point per day, handed out in person by Muscat. 03:15
- The rule that changes everything is that you can give an action point to a player in range instead of shooting them, which lets groups pool points for instant kills. 03:25
- Muscat expected a slow game of chicken, but within hours a faction of about 12 players funnelled points to one person, who took 12 actions and killed three players. 04:47
- Productivity plummeted over the eight days; an anonymous survey found 39% of players discussed the game 3–10 times a day and 18% more than 11 times. 06:49
- At least five non-playing employees fed information to players, and some were bribed with money to report who approached the glass-walled boardroom. 07:38
- Eliminated players joined a Survivor-style jury that voted daily; any player receiving three votes got an extra action point, which made grudges matter and invited lobbying. 08:24
- A group email thread, including anonymous messages, became a venue for grievances about co-workers, made worse by seniority differences and direct-report relationships among players. 10:38
- The game was stopped after eight days when players told Muscat it was changing how they felt about work; two players stopped speaking to each other for months. 11:23
Notable Quotes
“Yes there are action points and health, but really the true currency of this game is trust.”
“And so we’re all in agreement. I handed my tokens to this person, who just looked at me and said: ‘And now you’re dead’ and dropped the token into the box and just backstabbed me right there.”
“I like the strategizing to play directly off the rules, rather than play off the people”
Verified Claims
Claim: Tank Tactics was played by 17 Halfbrick employees and banned from the workplace after eight days.
- 02:08
- Sources: GDC Vault session overview, PocketGamer.biz interview
- Verdict: Confirmed. GDC’s own listing says 17 employees and 8 days, though Pocket Gamer and Engadget say nine days.
Claim: Luke Muscat was a designer at Halfbrick, the studio behind Fruit Ninja and Jetpack Joyride.
- 00:56
- Sources: Engadget, Game Developer on Prettygreat
- Verdict: Confirmed. He was Halfbrick’s chief creative officer at the time of the 2013 talk.
Claim: Players got one action point per day, could gift points to players in range, and eliminated players formed a jury that awarded extra points.
- 03:25
- Sources: Engadget, PocketGamer.biz GDC report
- Verdict: Confirmed. The three-vote threshold is not in the sources I read; Engadget says the jury granted one player an extra point each day.
Claim: Within hours, players daisy-chained their points to a single player who took 12 actions and killed three people.
Claim: At least five employees who were not playing fed information to players.
- 07:38
- Sources: Engadget, PocketGamer.biz GDC report
- Verdict: Confirmed for the spies (“up to five”). The cash bribes are not mentioned in the sources I read.
Claim: The jury mechanic was lifted from Survivor.
- 08:05
- Sources: PocketGamer.biz interview
- Verdict: Confirmed.
Claim: Neptune’s Pride, a web-based multi-week strategy game, was a direct inspiration for Tank Tactics.
- 08:58
- Sources: PocketGamer.biz interview, Wikipedia: Neptune’s Pride
- Verdict: Confirmed. Muscat says the action-point idea came from it.
Claim: Anonymous emails were sent as part of the conflict around the jury.
Claim: Two players stopped talking to each other and struggled to repair the relationship for months.
- 11:36
- Sources: GDC Vault session overview
- Verdict: Confirmed. The 2013 listing says two employees “still don’t speak to each other to this day”.
Claim: 39% of players discussed the game 3–10 times a day and 18% more than 11 times.
- 06:49
- Sources: Engadget, PocketGamer.biz GDC report
- Verdict: Inconclusive. Both confirm a survey existed, but report only that more than half of players had felt upset; the specific percentages are not in the sources I read.
Tools, Papers & Standards Mentioned
- Tank Tactics / Tank Turn Tactics — unreleased Halfbrick prototype; the canonical source is the GDC Vault session. A community Discord bot adaptation exists.
- Neptune’s Pride — Iron Helmet Games, with a rules introduction.
- Subterfuge — Wikipedia: Subterfuge (video game).
- Words with Friends — Wikipedia: Words with Friends.
- Survivor (TV show, source of the jury mechanic), Secret Hitler and The Thing (social deduction board games Muscat says he dislikes) — named in the video; no sources researched.
Follow-up Questions
- Muscat’s GDC talk blamed the lack of randomness for making every loss feel personal; would adding chance (hit rolls, random point drops) reduce the animosity without killing the engagement?
- How much of the damage came from the setting (colleagues, reporting lines, a visible physical board) rather than the rules, and do groups of strangers or friends playing the Discord adaptations report similar fallout?
- Muscat’s follow-up games with anonymous aliases reportedly failed because players identified each other by play style; is there any design for slow diplomacy-and-betrayal games that reliably keeps betrayal “in the game”?
Sources
- https://gdcvault.com/play/1017744
- https://www.engadget.com/2013-04-01-tank-tactics-the-prototype-that-almost-ruined-halfbrick.html
- https://www.pocketgamer.biz/halfbricks-luke-muscat-talks-tank-turn-tactics-the-prototype-the-studio-was-forced-to-ban/
- https://www.pocketgamer.biz/gdc-2013-how-a-game-that-never-was-almost-tore-halfbrick-apart/
- https://www.gamedeveloper.com/business/making-prettygreat-mobile-games-with-the-creator-of-i-fruit-ninja-i-
- https://neth0s.github.io/en/tank-tactics.html
- https://ironhelmet.com/
- https://np.ironhelmet.com/help/intro
- https://www.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neptune%27s_Pride
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subterfuge_(video_game)
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Words_with_Friends